As everyone knows, the irl trades has been allowed for a long period. However, irl deal scams still happens everywhere. The concerning part is that players who got irl deal scammed, the scammed items can be refunded or not. The important point is that irl deals featured in rare items such as Auto Sell Chests and a huge amount of In Game Balances, or even IGS / SFS. Those items should be refunded or ways to be returned when the specific player who have been confirmed got scammed by the following reasons. 1. Irl deals carries rare items, besides of a nice community built in skyblock servers, players often aim for selling in-game items for irl money. This is also one of the motivation for players to stay on Mineheroes. However, if the items got scammed and cannot be refunded, even through the scammer got banned, he still take a big advantage. When the items cannot be refunded, players who worked hard on reaching the items will be more unfair since they lost the items without any reasons or in any fair ways. 2. Whenever they check the chat logs history, or Paypal images / payment records, the staffs can easily know if someone got scammed or not by looking at them. However they have to gather enough in-game messages to proof that they trade the items for the IRL deals, and not only discord / other software messages. Whenever the player traded the items to the scammer, the items should be returned to the original item owner whenever they got punished. Although irl deal scamming problem happens in always, they should not be removed. Everything have both advantages and disadvantages but we have to investigate in it and make the whole system better. Since irl trades is one of the motivation for some MH players.